• linkedin
  • Increase Font
  • Sharebar

    White men need to do their part and make healthcare safe again

    Editor's Note: Welcome to Medical Economics' blog section which features contributions from members of the medical community. These blogs are an opportunity for bloggers to engage with readers about a topic that is top of mind, whether it is practice management, experiences with patients, the industry, medicine in general, or healthcare reform. The series continues with this blog by Monya De, MD, MPH, who practices internal medicine and integrative medicine in the Los Angeles area. The views expressed in these blogs are those of their respective contributors and do not represent the views of Medical Economics or UBM Medica.

     

    Monya De, MD, MPHThere were 440,000 people, mostly women, who marched on Washington a day after our latest presidential inauguration, with 750,000 marching in Los Angeles and 100,000 marching in London.

     

    More healthcare news: What a Gorsuch Supreme Court appointment would mean to healthcare

     

    Thousands marched, collectively, in Lithuania, Kenya, Antarctica, Poland and Tanzania.

    However, it didn’t matter to the new presidential administration, as it proceeded to issue proclamations weakening the mandate—the part that provides an incentive for healthy people to sign up for insurance—of the Affordable Care Act.

    With no mandate, and fewer healthy people signing up for insurance, overall costs rise. An executive order ended aid to organizations providing abortion services abroad, ensuring the birth of many more unwanted, hungry babies in developing countries.

    The current administration has everything it needs. Plenty of its voters support a Muslim ban (i.e., sending innocent Syrians back to slaughter) and bringing back pre-existing condition denials to health insurance. Food still gets delivered to the White House, suits are still pressed, the water and most of the lights are on. The machine isn’t stopping.

    Some who voted this administration into power continue to support its policies. They have a legal right to do so. However, for white men who do not support these policies, publicly denouncing these actions and removing support for politicians who engage in them is what the women’s march movement now needs.

     

    Further reading: The complicated puzzle of moving past Obamacare

     

    According to the Pew Research Center, of the votes that were successfully cast, the president carried whites by a margin of 21%, while he carried men by a margin of 12%. About 61% of white male registered voters are Republican, a full 10% more than the percentage of males of all races that are Republican.

    Next: "No other group has such power to send a message"

    Monya De, MD MPH
    Monya De, MD MPH (Twitter: @medjournalist) practices internal medicine and integrative medicine in the Los Angeles Area. She graduated ...

    16 Comments

    You must be signed in to leave a comment. Registering is fast and free!

    All comments must follow the ModernMedicine Network community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated. ModernMedicine reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part,in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

    • Anonymous
      I am a white male physician this article is correct. My vote means much more to the Republican leadership then the vote of a person of color or a woman or a disabled person. Those people don't even exist to the Republicans. Meanwhile I can pay my housekeeper less because she has free healthcare through Medicaid, but not care anywhere as good as what I get. I certainly don't want my teenage daughter to end up pregnant because she decided to buy cocktails at a bar instead of pay for birth control. White men benefit tremendously from the Affordable Care Act and its various protections.
    • Anonymous
      I am a white male physician this article is correct. My vote means much more to the Republican leadership then the vote of a person of color or a woman or a disabled person. Those people don't even exist to the Republicans. Meanwhile I can pay my housekeeper less because she has free healthcare through Medicaid, but not care anywhere as good as what I get. I certainly don't want my teenage daughter to end up pregnant because she decided to buy cocktails at a bar instead of pay for birth control. White men benefit tremendously from the Affordable Care Act and its various protections.
    • Anonymous
      I am a white male physician this article is correct. My vote means much more to the Republican leadership then the vote of a person of color or a woman or a disabled person. Those people don't even exist to the Republicans. Meanwhile I can pay my housekeeper less because she has free healthcare through Medicaid, but not care anywhere as good as what I get. I certainly don't want my teenage daughter to end up pregnant because she decided to buy cocktails at a bar instead of pay for birth control. White men benefit tremendously from the Affordable Care Act and its various protections.
    • UBM User
      The fact that Medical Economics would publish this article, by this author says a lot. Monya De has been allowed a platform in this publication in the past. I wonder if Medical Economics would allow an author to write about "brown women"? If you want to do a Google search regarding Monya De, MD and her behavior as a resident at Catholic Heathcare West as an Internal Medicine resident, that will tell you all you need to know about what type of person she is. She and her opinions are one of many reasons why Donald Trump won the election.
    • Anonymous
      This article reflects the liberal media had contaminated the Medical Economics publication. How bad is it to say " unwanted hungry babies" .This is double discrimination --- discrimating by at ( babies) and attacking white men. I am An Asian woman physician who's a Catholic. Who's looking out for me? My insurance premium went sky high and so did my deductible. I don't mind legalizing abortion --- but paying for it too? Where is personal responsibility here? And did you say the US is also supporting abortion from other countries? Why should the US be responsible for all developing countries, Syrian seeking asylum? There are other C developed countries besides US, I can tell Dr De must not be working as a solo practice in a small community. If she did she will see where her tax dollars go. To people who migrate without going through legalities that I had to do through the years. Yes it's better to be undocumented, get all of government handouts get free college food stamps and Medicaid. The legal ones have to pay taxes, borrow money for college and work their butts off to pay for self and millions of pretend unemployed people. Where's the justice in that? I invite Dr De to work for me in my office.
    • Anonymous
      This article reflects the liberal media had contaminated the Medical Economics publication. How bad is it to say " unwanted hungry babies" .This is double discrimination --- discrimating by at ( babies) and attacking white men. I am An Asian woman physician who's a Catholic. Who's looking out for me? My insurance premium went sky high and so did my deductible. I don't mind legalizing abortion --- but paying for it too? Where is personal responsibility here? And did you say the US is also supporting abortion from other countries? Why should the US be responsible for all developing countries, Syrian seeking asylum? There are other C developed countries besides US, I can tell Dr De must not be working as a solo practice in a small community. If she did she will see where her tax dollars go. To people who migrate without going through legalities that I had to do through the years. Yes it's better to be undocumented, get all of government handouts get free college food stamps and Medicaid. The legal ones have to pay taxes, borrow money for college and work their butts off to pay for self and millions of pretend unemployed people. Where's the justice in that? I invite Dr De to work for me in my office.
    • DROGERSMD@------.COM
      This is insulting garbage. Racism and bigotry is not the problem with the Trump presidency or administration. It is the problem of idiots like this author and her journalist buddies, who have nearly regressed into childlike demeanor since the election. Obamacare is a disaster. We cannot control costs with no pre-exiting conditions and a personal mandate. The economics do not work. When we can finally have a rational conversation between both sides, we can make a difference.
    • ncalmd@------.com
      Although I'm not surprised to see the editorial staff trying to advance a political agenda, I am surprised they couldn't find someone who could write an article consistent with the intelligence level and occupations of the majority of their readers. But then again, maybe its difficult to find someone who could make a rational argument for the ACA. Even those who constructed this bill, knew it wouldn't work. There may be good arguments for expansion of Medicaid, and there may be good arguments for government subsidizing the premiums of those with pre-existing illness. But please don't confuse those arguments with legislation so flawed that even those who crafted this monstrosity knew it wouldn't work. (For the record, I have been a strong proponent for national healthcare for the past 15 years, as I see no other way to contain the costs of a system with ever expanding legal and regulatory burdens) I would however be interested in Dr. Monya De, providing a reference to the studies showing how many lives have been saved by the ACA, and perhaps explaining the relationship of funding foreign abortions, and Syrian refugees to the lives she claims will be lost if the ACA is repealed. Then again, if Dr. Monya De and editors were simply using this publication to exhort those male readers sharing their particular agenda of causes, do your readers a favor and simply identify future article as political messages.
    • wickedgrin1@------.com
      ..
    • wickedgrin1@------.com
      Monya De is a typical establishment wonk using her medical degree and a healthy weight of implied racism to club people into supporting collective solutions to individual problems. “But white men who believe in a healthier country, one where people do not die needlessly from lack of access to medical care, have a chance to make a difference. The women who marched have already done their part.” So I can atone for my white guilt by supporting your nationalized health care? Monya De’s comments are racist and sexist, and her prescriptions of categorical guilt won’t cure a damn thing. It is curious to see Medical Economics' increasingly leftward slant.
    • Anonymous
      What Racist offensive liberal propaganda of alleged facts . My facts: Obamacare triple increased my insurance premiums and deductible for services I will never use. If you are really a practicing physician and take insurance you would have heard the same from the majority of your patients. Why would we support and pay for abortions in foreign countries? Ludicrous! Why should we support your liberal agenda? Incredible! I am surprised this magazine published this article. PS I am Hispanic
    • UBM User
      As a Italian/American Female I am appauld by this article and the amount of reversed racisim it spews! You take pride in a womens march that doesnt include all women! The marches excluded women who are Pro-life! Your whole group doesnt speak for all women, nor should your opinion stereotype all white men! My son is a white male who is gay and a Registered Republican and a conservative. I grew up in the 70s and 80s and the womens movement was not what these women stsnd for, we fought for equality! This group wants equality only for certain things and when a man treats them as he would any other man that man is called sexist! Figure what you want then protest! ACA isnt the best law and why should there be mandates for white men that cant afford it, if you want to also do the research on how those of us with private insurance with pre-existing conditions were thrown under the financial bus because of ACA. I am one of them, i have lost more than 50% of my already depleted monthly income when i went on disability and now due do ACA i no longer qualify for copay assistance and I have to pay for one medication out of pocket of 3800.00 US dollars; i dont make that much so now i have to consider food or medicine! The female actresses used their fame to bully the president and while at it his daughter. So the support of the hatred and bullying of others have done nothing but make them look like fools. The left shouldn't count their eggs before they hatch while their leaders are making even bigger fools. Like Schumer who has sponsored a child molestation athlete in NY! As for the abortion issue listen to what the conservatives are saying versus what the liberals (and quote Clinton if i need to) there needs to be some type of cut off on when well i tried to fix where i left off and i lost all of it... will try again to compose my thoughts.
    • UBM User
      i have tried several times to fix the response above, it has wiped out everything I write. So I will try it a different way.
    • Anonymous
      Racist. Medical Economics has reached a new low. I'm Hispanic and even I find this racist and offensive! BTW, BHO is half white; but I guess that's never mentioned since it's not politically expedient - doesn't serve the liberal agenda.
    • UBM User
      As one who has been around the block and a long time provider through decades of change, I find this to be racist, sexist, and offensive press. Why not add ageism ("Old White Men need...") to your neo-socialist blogger's identity politic bullets? Keep it on social media where the naïve believe each others' opinions are more important than others, with consideration of any opposing or potential promise for positive change.
    • neuropod@------.net
      As a long time conservative and supporter of Trump, I find the title of your article disconcerting based on the assumption that all Trump supporters are white, and in the general media we are also characterized as being uneducated. You are right that many women marched after the inauguration but these marches were not about the ACA but did have many speakers that spewed vile hate rhetoric. It appears that being female and of foreign descent does not exempt you from racist views. I would suggest that you should focus on the needs of physicians such as tort reform and the repeal of unfunded mandates such as MACRA that interfere with time needed to care for patients and have no bearing on quality care.

    Latest Tweets Follow