Planning your next move when wrongly accused of medical malpractice
Countersuing may be tempting, but other paths could be more productive
Getting sued for malpractice is every doctor's nightmare. The fact that more than 42% of physicians have been sued during their careers, according to an American Medical Association survey, provides little solace. The public assault on your reputation and the emotional anguish you'll face can be devastating even when the lawsuit is completely frivolous.
In some notorious cases, plaintiffs' attorneys have sued the wrong doctor about a patient he never even met, refused to drop a lawsuit despite having no expert witness until the physician made a settlement offer, and re-filed a case against a doctor when the plaintiff's own expert said no negligence existed.
Courts sanctioned the attorneys in those cases, but egregious behavior by plaintiffs, their attorneys, and expert witnesses continues to flourish and usually goes unpunished. The desire by physicians to retaliate against these sleazy tactics is palpable. If you find yourself in such a situation, turning the tables on these adversaries would provide some emotional satisfaction for the havoc they've wrought in your life.
 Lee J. Johnson, JD |
Countersuits rarely succeed for plenty of other reasons, and we'll discuss those later.
Despite the odds against them, more doctors and their medical societies are fighting back against dishonest lawyering and bogus witness testimony. They've scored some impressive victories.
 Jeffrey Segal, MD, JD, FACS |
Here are some of the victories.
• Court sanctions attorney who sued the wrong doctor
Ob-gyn Ward P. Vaughan, MD, was sued in 2004 over an obstetrical procedure performed at a Front Royal, Virginia, hospital where he's never had privileges. He also never had met the patient.
Plaintiff's attorney Michael P. Weatherbee, JD, reviewed an operative report that noted the lead surgeon was assisted by "Bob Vaughan," according to court records. Several Vaughans were listed on the Virginia Board of Medicine's Web site, and Weatherbee wrongly assumed he'd picked the correct one to sue.
The unjustly accused Vaughan ultimately was dismissed from the case and then filed a complaint with the Virginia State Bar Association. An investigation quickly determined that Weatherbee had committed professional misconduct, including filing a frivolous lawsuit and failing to act with competence and diligence.
Although the penalty was merely a public reprimand, Weatherbee appealed to the Virginia Supreme Court, which unanimously upheld the finding.
The high court noted that Weatherbee did not take even "simple" steps to adequately research Vaughan's involvement, such as verifying his hospital privileges or contacting his office regarding the patient's medical records.
"The lawsuit had a deleterious impact upon Dr. Vaughan's practice," the court held. "He lost patients, and he was subjected to ridicule and scorn. A local radio station repeatedly informed its listeners, approximately once each hour for a full day, that Dr. Vaughan had been sued for medical malpractice. Also, the litigation against Dr. Vaughan was reported on a local television station."
MORE ARTICLES IN THIS ISSUE
Poll: Healthcare reform will harm PCPs
A majority of healthcare providers think primary care physicians (PCPs) will be worse off after all aspects of healthcare reform are implemented than they are now, according to a recent survey by Managed Healthcare Executive.
Healthcare spending growth remains slow
Healthcare spending saw its second consecutive year of slow growth in 2010, mostly due to the poor economy, according to government analysts.
Waiving copays puts you at risk for fraud
Collecting copays can be a hassle for your practice. But waiving them can get you in hot water.
Revised ACP ethics manual urges focus on care that is cost-effective
Physicians should base their advice on what's best for the patient but also consider the cost of treatment, according to the latest edition of the American College of Physicians Ethics Manual.
Don't let your emotions affect your finances
Income alone doesn't mean financial success, especially if emotional investing is clouding your judgment.
Most hospital errors not reported
Only one in seven errors, accidents, and other events that harm hospitalized Medicare patients, is recognized and reported, federal investigators say.
Before you consider what will happen with a Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services accountable care organization, first decide whether joining one is right for you. Get the experts' take on the future of the ACO.
Ask patients how they prefer to be addressed
Find out if calling your patients by their full names is a violation of HIPAA ... or just plain rude.
Plan 5 years ahead of selling your medical practice
In tough economic times, the rules of retiring and selling your practice have changed. See what you need to ensure an orderly transition.
Texas health assistance program set to fold
The TEXAS Consumer Health Assistance Program, which helps consumers find affordable health insurance, is expected to close due to lack of federal funding.
Letters: Readers comment on Medical Economics stories
Letters discuss how EHR systems affect workload, and why private solo doctors may soon be extinct.
4 questions to ask before joining an ACO
Don't make the decision to practice in an accountable care organization lightly. Push hospital or delivery network admins to give you straight talk on these pressing points.
Revenue-expenses-profit: A plan for 2012
Get creative and make this your medical practice's most successful year yet.
Consider tax consequences in retirement portfolio
See why you should think about taxes when it comes to retirement planning.
Crisis management for your medical practice
Learn how to ensure your practice survives a disaster like the death of an owner.
Outsmart the IRS: Income tax changes for 2012-13
Strategies implemented before your tax liability is set in stone could make you rich in the long run.
Keep your work computer free of viruses to avoid problems
Computer viruses can grind your practice to a halt and open up the possibility of lawsuits. Learn how to keep your system virus-free.
Address claim issues before 5010 conversion
Questions include claim issues with 5010, RAC demand letters, and telehealth services. Find out the answers to pressing coding questions.
How to know if the money you have now will last you through retirement
Discover a tool known as the Monte Carlo simulation and how it can help you plan for retirement and ease your worries about depleting your savings.
How the tax code could cure what ails healthcare
Discover how the tax code could make uncompensated/undercompensated care a thing of the past.
FDA creating mobile app for use during public health crises
Prompted by the 2009 H1N1 influenza outbreak, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) plans to create a mobile app to help it gather information and send out alerts about adverse reactions to experimental medications prescribed during a public health crisis.
New funds transfer rules expected to save time, money
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) says new rules governing electronic funds transfers, along with other changes that make it easier to check patients' health coverage eligibility and the status of claims, will save the national healthcare system more than $16 billion over the next decade.
Cancer deaths continue their steady decline
The rate of death from cancer in the United States continues to drop, the American Cancer Society reports. See which populations are having more birthdays.
Medical Economics gathered several experts together at the National Society of Certified Healthcare Business Consultants 2011 annual meeting to share insights about accountable care organizations and Patient-Centered Medical Homes to help you and your colleagues decide whether to consider these options for practice.
