• linkedin
  • Increase Font
  • Sharebar

    The man behind MOC defends the program against critics


     ME: Despite the cost and time commitment required for that? 

    RB: The bulk of the time commitment is staying current in a rapidly-changing field. If we went out of business tomorrow, doctors would still need to spend a ton of uncompensated time reading journals, coming to meetings like this, studying. We don’t make people do that. We recognize that they have, and give them a way to acknowledge that they’ve done what they needed to do.

     ME : That’s a good segue to my next question, which is that doctors say that between requirements for CME and the easy access to information on the internet, that more than keeps them abreast of developments in their field, so why certify at all?

    RB: First of all, the wide availability of the internet, the patients have that too. Yet there’s a significant difference in what we expect from patients with regard to knowledge and ability and what we expect from physicians with regard to knowledge and ability. So doctors know stuff that patients don’t know. And when they’re seeing patients—and I was in practice for many years—if you had to look up everything on every patient you see you’d never get through the day. 

    So everyone’s doing the time-lookup balance, so the more you know the sager you’re going to be in managing that tension. So the first thing I’d say is the availability of the internet doesn’t mean that knowledge doesn’t matter.  

    Further reading: Top 10 challenges facing physicians this year


    The second thing is everyone agrees CME varies enormously in quality and effectiveness. Everyone knows about courses you can go to on the cruise or at the ski resort and may or may not be getting any knowledge. And it’s important not just that your seat was in the seat, but that you actually know what you need to know to do what we do. And what we do is pretty important and it changes pretty rapidly and people are not good at assessing what they don’t know. People assume that what they know is the right thing, but as one of my colleagues said some years ago, 30 years of practice doing it the wrong way doesn’t make it right. And how you keep up and learn with changes is an important thing all of us care about.

    And one more comment with respect to the internet. There are now credentials available on the internet too. My son’s getting married this month by somebody who went on the internet and clicked “become an ordained minister for free.” And he got that credential, and he’ll marry my son with legal authority in the state of New York. It’s OK with me that he’s marrying my son, it wouldn’t be OK if he was providing healthcare to my son. And I think most of us really are proud of having a credential that distinguishes us in a world where what’s behind that credential really makes it valuable.

     ME: But of course, that’s not the same thing as getting licensed to practice medicine. There is a lot more that’s required of you to do that.

    RB: That’s true, but once you are licensed, first of all, only 81% of doctors are board-certified, 19% are not. So one in five doctors in this country is a licensed doctor who’s not board-certified, and I assume most of them are working. 

    Next: What about the cutoff date?


    You must be signed in to leave a comment. Registering is fast and free!

    All comments must follow the ModernMedicine Network community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated. ModernMedicine reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part,in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

    • UBM User
      Reading this reminds me of a farmer mandating all his chickens learn how to make more and better eggs. Nothing good for the chickens, only making more money for the farmer.
    • UBM User
      Oh yes! Doctors need the self reassure cr of being able to pass an exam!! Where does he come off speaking for other docs? He is simply justifying his existence which is a disgraceful attempt to perpetuate this ignorant process. Come forward with real evidence that justifies his belief and we'll listen. O/W all the docs beholden to this process need to rise up against and walk swiftly from these mandates! Remember that the hospital needs you!!
    • UBM User
      The arrogance of these people is astounding. It's just like Washington, DC, just on a smaller scale. The rules don't apply to them. Rules are for the peasants. Just like Hillary Clinton, who is never held accountable for anything she does. All animals are equal, but some are more equal than others...
    • [email protected]
      "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.” ― Upton Sinclair
    • Anonymous
      "Doctor" Baron is just another wacky didactic physician gone wild administrator making rules and regs from his Ivory tower. Rules he'll never have to follow cause he makes 'em up as he goes. MOC is a farce
    • Anonymous
      Said the physician executive from the study of his million dollar home.

    Latest Tweets Follow