• linkedin
  • Increase Font
  • Sharebar

    Physicians gather to fight UnitedHealthcare’s Medicare network cancellations

    The Hartford County and Fairfield County medical associations in Connecticut took their fight against UnitedHealthcare to a town hall meeting November 26, in front of prominent federal and state legislators, as well as doctors from across the state. UnitedHealthcare has removed more than 2,200 physicians from its Medicare Advantage program in the state.

    The two medical associations have taken UnitedHealthcare to federal court in Bridgeport, Connecticut, with a hearing scheduled for Dec. 3 before U.S. District Judge Stefan Underhill. They are seeking a temporary restraining order preventing the health insurer from removing the physicians—about 20 percent of the UnitedHealthcare provider panel—from its Medicare Advantage networks. Anywhere from 20,000 to 30,000 patients could be affected, the medical associations claim.

    Bollepalli Subbarao, MD, president of the Hartford County Medical Association, said his group is confident the judge will grant the restraining order but concedes the ruling might go against the group because contract language does permit the cancellation. One tactic that might work is a class action suit by the patients. “We need to think about other options,” he said.

    During the meeting, Michael P. Connair, MD, an orthopedist from North Haven, Conn., called on his medical colleagues—not acting in collusion—to quit working for UnitedHealthcare. “The individual actions of many doctors can bring an insurance company to its knees and threaten its economic vitality,” he told the audience of 63, which included legislators, doctors, patients and association staff, at the West Hartford Meeting and Convention Center.

    Connair, who is a member of the National Union of Hospital and Health Care Employees, as well as the Federation of Physicians and Dentists, cited actions physicians took in Ohio and Rhode Island when insurers sought to cut reimbursement rates. The physician departure from the insurance companies left them without enough doctors to provide adequate coverage in their networks. "UnitedHealthcare crumbles pretty quickly if they don't have the services for their patients," he said.

    U.S. Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT) said the entire Connecticut Congressional delegation has been conferring with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) to push the federal agency to determine the adequacy of UnitedHealthcare's network in the wake of so many doctors being cut. "We're determined to use every bit of persuasion available to us," he said, slamming UnitedHealthcare for not being responsive to legislative calls for information on its decision, which he said was done "simply to fatten the bottom line of UnitedHealthcare."

    As previously reported
    by Medical Economics, thousands of physicians in Arkansas, Florida, Indiana, Nebraska, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Rhode Island, Texas, and Utah are believed to have been impacted by recent network cancellations by health insurance companies. The American Medical Association (AMA) adds that cancellations have also been reported by physicians from Anthem, Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans, and Humana. The AMA, with 81 other medical groups, including the American College of Physicians and American Osteopathic Association, said the terminations were “without cause” and called on Marilyn Tavenner, administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) to address the “lack of Medicare Advantage sponsor transparency on network adequacy.”

    At yesterday’s meeting, Blumenthal told Medical Economics in a brief interview, "My hope is [CMS] will be responsive. If they're not, I'm not sure what the next step will be. I won't discuss our options beyond that. We're not in the business of making threats but we will consider the alternatives," he said.

    UnitedHealthcare did not return a telephone call for comment. Bryan Carroll, UnitedHealthcare’s associate general counsel, did confirm its Medicare Advantage network in Connecticut includes 3,000 primary care physicians and 4,400 specialists in correspondence with the state of Connecticut’s Attorney General George Jepsen.

    UnitedHealthcare’s Carroll says in written correspondence that there are many factors involved with the decision. “All of them relate to providing a network of physicians who we can collaborate with to help enhance health plan quality, improve healthcare outcomes, and curb the growth in healthcare costs. Decisions about which doctors will remain part of our network can include the number of patients who are covered by our plans, the relative adequacy of our network in a particular market, and the type of contract we have with the doctor.”

    At yesterday’s meeting, Laureen Rubino, MD, a general surgeon from Manchester, Connecticut, warned of dire times ahead if doctors don't win this fight against UnitedHealthcare. "This is going to affect us with all insurance companies if we don't take a stand," she said. "It will spread to other insurance companies if we don't stop this."

    Rubino called on physicians to vet payer contracts with insurers and attorneys.
    "Whoever thought they could cut you out of the entire program?" she said, a point driven home when a UnitedHealthcare representative told her office manager the move was taken because it was allowed in her contract.

    In her practice, Rubino said, 35 patients are affected her practice’s network cancellation. "It's difficult because there's no criteria. I don't have malpractice. I don't have any issues. I do the third most robotic surgeries in Connecticut. The way they did it, I can't take care of my patients any more."

    6 Comments

    You must be signed in to leave a comment. Registering is fast and free!

    All comments must follow the ModernMedicine Network community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated. ModernMedicine reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part,in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

    • Dr. Segal
      Why does everyone comment as anonymous? Perhaps the main issue with why doctors take it in the back side is because we do not have the gall to step-up, unite and stand together. First and foremost, in an age of "accountability" insurance companies have less accountability than ever and do whatever they want without check nor balance. The reason is simple: They pay congress off to get the rules and laws they want. It is high time that WE as physicians stuck together and dropped THEM!
    • Anonymous
      UH is in process of committing suicide as an insurer. By rushing to drop primary care physicians, they have, first, breached their contract with the existing panel (for which they can, and will, be successfully sued by those excluded); second, made all their plans immediately toxic to any employer whose employees currently use one of the excluded physicians; third, taken a resource already in short supply and made the supply even shorter for their enrollees. Were I insured with United, I would be headed for the exits RIGHT NOW!!! (Please pay heed, all AARP members!!! This insurer has demontrated that its management is irredeemably STUPID and SELF-DESTRUCTIVE!!!) If UH thinks it is too big to fail, I have news for it: At the moment, health insurance companies are ANATHEMA to the Obama administration, as well as to most Americans, and NO insurance company that misbehaves so incredibly will be allowed to survive. I imagine that most Congresspeople are also pretty fed up with the health insures--at least those in Congress who did not shed their brains after being elected.
    • Anonymous
      I enrolled with UH partially because of AARP's promotion of their Advantage plan. I learned recently that UH no longer has a contract with one of the most prestigious cancer centers in the United States here in FL. As a retired Internist and Geriatrician who now volunteers at a local free clinic in FL, I am peronally disgusted by UH's business decision (motivated by greed) and outraged by AARP's silence on this issue.
    • Anonymous
      UH is a successful business-they have already agreed upon their plans with the president behind closed doors.They get guaranteed payment for all patients from taxpayer moneys(what other money does the government have to allocate) They in turn have to decrease specialists who are outliers in cost/expenditures so as to control physicians. AARP advertise for UH; I received a job offer from UH 2 weeks ago to be a physician who monitors the care of other physicians in the network.My job would be to decide if the doctor's care complied with UH's performance indicators.The president's plan demands a monthly report of these indicators and the insurer must penalize the unsatisfactory physicians. The point being-unless we fight back with a plan that works for patients and providers and avoid rewarding the insurers whose goals are profit only, we are deluded in believing this socialist president's plans can be averted. I have worked in 3 different health care systems and this present american system spends more for less results;what if we gave 1.5% of our income to a healthcare system for all legal residents and allowed providers upto 40% private practice with 60% public. No worries about state lines since all legal residents are covered from birth and over time primary care will grow and specialties will diminish via competition.Overall cost is lower and patients get value for the tax dollar with less administration "overhead" Be brave and trust only when verified
    • Anonymous
      Th only options for physicians in the United States is to unionize and let the country feel the full effect of their power! Don't fall for the old story that we are professionals and this would not be consistent with our image. Get over it! You are now a medical provider like any other service provider and we should organize like any other service providers in this country. Look at the strength and power of the teachers union. Forget about the AMA they don't have the testicular fortitude for the fight that is needed. Wake up Docs,your very existance is in the balance!
    • Anonymous
      I do agree ,with the Anonymous comment, we are so weak because we are divided, afraid and not aware of the priviledge and the strength we have as Medical Doctor.The Insurance company have used the Doctors because we let them do it for the Love of money or the Lack of courage. It is time to said enough with The Intermediary.

    Latest Tweets Follow

    Poll